EVCostPerMile

Lease or buy a used electric car?

Leasing looks cheap until your mileage changes. Here's how to compare a lease with buying a used EV, with a calculator.

By Sam Wrench, Polestar 2 owner and founder of EVCostPerMile. Updated 17 November 2026.

Quick answer: leasing suits you if your mileage is predictable and you like a new car every few years. Buying a used EV that's still under warranty usually wins if you drive a lot, your mileage might rise, or you keep cars for a long time, because there are no excess mileage charges and you own the car at the end.

My story: why I switched from leasing to buying used

My first EV was a Mercedes EQC on a personal lease, and it was genuinely good value. But I chose my mileage allowance when I was doing about 5,000 miles a year on a local job. Then I started a job in Manchester, my mileage jumped and I ended up paying excess mileage charges.

So next time I bought a used 2023 Polestar 2 Long Range, about three years old and still under warranty. Now I can drive as far as I need, maintenance has been cheap, and once the final interest-free payment is made the car is mine to keep running for years.

Compare the total cost

Enter the figures from a real lease quote and a real used car advert. We don't quote prices ourselves.

Lease

Used EV

You

Over –: leasing costs about – (including – in excess mileage), buying used costs about –.

Lease total = initial payment + monthly payments + excess miles. Used total = price − value at the end + interest + extra servicing. Charging costs are the same either way, so they're left out. A lease usually includes a new-car warranty and sometimes servicing.

Leasing vs buying a used EV

LeaseUsed EV
Upfront costInitial rental (often 3–9 months)Deposit or full price
MileageFixed allowance, charged per extra mileUnlimited
Battery and value riskNone, you hand it backYours, but usually warranty-backed
At the endHand back, pay for damage beyond fair wear and tearYou own it
Best forPredictable mileage, a new car every few yearsHigh or changing mileage, keeping cars longer

Comparing lease deals

If leasing suits you, compare deals from lots of brokers at once, and check the excess mileage rate as well as the monthly price. I found my EQC lease on Leasing.com.

Compare electric car lease deals →

Leasing.com is a marketplace for lease deals from brokers and funders. We may earn a commission if you make an enquiry through this link. Leasing is a form of finance: check the full terms, total cost and mileage limits before you sign.

Work out the charging costs for any EV →

Frequently asked questions

What is an excess mileage charge?

If you drive more than the mileage in your lease contract, you pay a set amount for every extra mile when you hand the car back. Rates commonly range from about 5p to 30p a mile, and some are higher, so check the figure in the contract before you sign.

Is it better to lease or buy a used electric car?

It depends on your mileage and how long you keep cars. Leasing gives you a new car with fixed monthly costs and no worries about battery value, but limits your miles. A used EV that's still under warranty can be much cheaper over several years and lets you drive as far as you like.

Is a used EV's battery a worry?

Most manufacturers warranty the battery for 8 years (often 100,000 miles), so a three-year-old EV usually has around five years of battery cover left. Ask for a battery health report before you buy.

Can I change my lease mileage?

Some leasing companies let you adjust the allowance during the contract, usually not in the first 12 months or final 6 months. It's cheaper to change it early than to pay excess charges at the end.

Get told when EV prices change

Free email alerts when EV tariffs or the price cap change. Sign up.